Originally Posted by
TheBang
You know, I can't think of anything off-hand. As you say, in the past, it was usually just "with Trent Reznor" or "featuring Trent Reznor" or produced by or remixed by. The closest I can I think of is "I'm Afraid of Americans". While ostensibly just a remix, it really became essentially a collaboration, with NIN doing credited remix and production duties on the most of the remix single, the V1 remix becoming the definitive version of the song, and that remix version and Trent featuring in the music video.